How often should a sportsground be aerated? What a 12-month compaction study showed

Many schools and councils aerate their fields once or twice a year and hope that is enough. Gilba Solutions wanted evidence, so it followed a sportsground in constant use for twelve months, measuring compaction through the soil profile before and after different aeration treatments.
Five questions the study set out to answer
- How much does regular use compact the soil?
- Which relieves compaction better: vertidraining or hollow tine aeration?
- How effective is each one?
- How long does the relief last when the ground stays in constant use?
- Does the ground need aerating on a regular schedule?
How compaction was measured
Readings were taken at several depths through the profile and tracked over time. The benchmark was 2000 kPa: above that figure, compaction is generally regarded as tight enough to limit root growth.
Hollow tine aeration and vertidraining started in August 2021, with further aeration from December 2021.
What the ground looked like at the start
Compaction was present both near the surface and deeper down. In practice that showed up as poor drainage, with water lying on the surface after rain.
What the year of readings showed
- Hollow tining did more for the surface layer. Vertidraining was the less effective of the two for compaction near the top of the profile.
- Using both worked best. The combined treatment cut compaction more than either method on its own.
- Deep compaction stayed. Even the combined approach did not shift the high readings below about 50 mm, and some areas stayed above 2000 kPa after aeration.
- Play undid the work quickly. Under constant use, the benefit lasted three months at most.
- Fine soils need more attention. The higher the fines content, the more often aeration is needed.
What it means for a school or council ground
Compaction relief is a program, not a one-off job. On a ground in constant use, one or two aerations a year will not keep up. Gilba's recommendations from the study were to:
- aerate as often as the schedule allows
- combine vertidraining with hollow tine aeration
- plan specifically for compaction at depth, not just at the surface
- keep the program running all year rather than reacting after a bad season
A surface hardness test with a cone penetrometer is a quick way to find out where your own ground sits against the 2000 kPa line. It is one of the agronomic services Gilba offers, and Gilba's article on the science behind soil aeration explains the background.
